Transition to clean energy is beneficial for economic development
On October 26, the official website of the ETH Zurich in Switzerland reported that upgrading the energy system and achieving the goal of net zero emissions can obtain net benefits, according to the comprehensive foreign media report of China Social Science Daily.
Anthony Pat, a climate policy professor at the school, said that people generally believe that transitioning to clean energy requires additional economic costs because the construction and operation costs of renewable energy systems are higher than those of fossil energy systems. The relevant studies of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and the Swiss Federal Energy Office also show that a strong climate policy will not be conducive to economic growth. However, researchers at the school have found that even if it is not to address climate change, there should be a shift towards clean energy, and this measure is beneficial for economic development.
Researchers have stated that the IPCC and many other organizations generally use the Integrated Assessment Model for Climate Change (IAM) when predicting the economic costs of climate protection. This model assumes that people will choose the cheapest energy supply method at any time, and the government's main approach to encouraging people to choose low-carbon energy is to continuously increase carbon taxes. The model predicts that carbon taxes need to be high enough to incentivize people to invest in expensive new energy technologies such as solar, wind, and carbon neutral aviation fuels, which may lead to a significant increase in related consumer prices, thereby suppressing economic activity and growth.
However, the reality is completely different from the predictions. The investment in solar and wind energy is much higher than predicted by international assessment reports, and the actual costs are also lower than predicted. Moreover, the climate policies driving these changes are not carbon taxes, but subsidies and regulations. Therefore, researchers hope to understand what impact the clean energy transformation will have on the economy if it continues.
The Energy Science Center of the school has studied the conversion of Switzerland's energy system and the specific implementation of net zero emission targets. Researchers simulated electricity market prices and international trade flows. The study assumes that Switzerland will continue its current energy policy and calculate the energy costs of Switzerland after complete decarbonization by 2040 based on different assumptions about whether Switzerland will integrate into the European electricity market in the future.
In the first scenario, if Switzerland continues to stay on the European power grid, market simulation results indicate that Switzerland will continue to export electricity in the summer and import electricity in the winter. However, by 2040, the use of oil and natural gas to support transportation and heating will be completely eliminated, resulting in a slight increase in net imported electricity. Therefore, even if electricity prices decrease, Switzerland's total electricity expenditure will increase by about 500 million Swiss francs. However, deducting the additional cost of carbon neutral fuels, reducing fossil fuels can save Switzerland approximately 2.5 billion Swiss francs. Compared to now, Switzerland will save approximately 2 billion Swiss francs annually by 2040.
In the second scenario, if Switzerland fails to continue to stay in the European electricity market, leading to a decrease in international transmission capacity, it is necessary to increase investment in domestic renewable energy generation to increase electricity generation. Compared to the first scenario, the cost of electricity will increase by about 40%. However, combined with the cost reduction caused by reducing the use of fossil fuels, the overall energy cost is still lower than the current level.
Previously, a study by the University of Oxford in the UK also found consistent results, stating that by 2030, the expected energy cost of a net zero emission solution will be slightly lower than that of a non transition to clean energy, and by 2040, the former will be 20% lower than the latter. Researchers have stated that neither the Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich nor the University of Oxford have translated the saved energy costs into global annual GDP growth. However, in reality, under the net zero emission plan, economic growth will be faster as energy costs and prices decrease.
After adopting the optimized model framework and data, both recent research results indicate that climate protection policies can bring a win-win situation for economic development and environmental protection, which will increase momentum for accelerating decarbonization actions.
2022-11-09